IS0 14001 – Setting Environmental Standards

S. Karthik

The International Organisation for Standardisation (ISO), a non-governmental organisation situated in Geneva, Switzerland established in 1947, comprises a worldwide federation of national standards bodies from each of 100 countries. The organisation aims to facilitate the international exchange of goods and services by establishing international standards and reconciling regulatory differences between countries. ISO has published over 9600 standards, most of these are product standards related to manufacturing and performance of specific products. There are also two series of management standards developed. These are:

n ISO 9000 series, which includes standards and guide-lines for quality assurance and management
n ISO 14000 series, which includes organisational evaluation standard and the standard for product, services and processes

The ISO 14000 series is a voluntary set of standards intended to encourage organizations to systematically address the environmental impacts of their activities. The goal is to establish a common approach to environmental management systems that is internationally recognized, leading to improved environmental protection and reducing barriers to international trade.

ISO 14000 is a management system standard, not a performance standard. It is intended to be applicable to firms of all shapes and sizes around the world. The standard does not require specific environmental goals. Instead, it provides a general framework for organizing the tasks necessary for effective environmental management.

The series of documents that encompass ISO 14000 includes components such as environmental management systems, environmental auditing, environmental labeling, and product life cycle assessment. The ISO 14001 standard, which lays out requirements for establishing an Environmental Management System (EMS), is the centerpiece of the series. In order to qualify for ISO certification, firms must meet the requirements laid out in the ISO 14001. All of the other standards in the ISO 14000 series provide supporting guidance.

Emergence of ISO 14000

The world’s first standard for EMS – BS 7750 was developed and published by the British Standard Institute (BSI) in 1992. This standard was the model for the ISO 14000 series developed, which established the requirements for an EMS, and was finalised in 1996. BS 7750 was also the basis for the European Union’s Eco-Management and Audit Scheme, known as EMAS.

ISO 14000 series focuses on two major areas in the evaluation of environmental management practice. One area focuses on organisational issues and the other on product, services and processes.

The standard for organisational evaluation includes:

« Environmental Management Systems (ISO 14001, ISO 14004)
« Environmental Performance Evaluation (ISO 14014, ISO 14015, ISO 14031)
« Environmental Auditing (ISO 14010, 14011, 14012, 14013, 14014)
The standard for product, services and processes includes:
« Life Cycle assessment (ISO 14040, 14041, 14042, 14043)
« Environmental Labeling (ISO 14020, 14021, 14022, 14023, 14024)
« Environmental Aspects in product standards (ISO 14060)

Environmental Management System (EMS)

ISO defines EMS as the part of overall management system that includes organisational structure, planning activities, responsibilities, practices, procedures, processes and resources for developing, implementing, achieving, reviewing and maintaining the environmental policy. An EMS is the management structure and system that organisations can use to address the short and long-term impacts of their products, services, and processes on the environment.

As discussed earlier, EMS standards are process-related standards and not performance related standards. In other words, these standards do not tell organisations what environmental performance they must achieve besides environmental regulations compliance. Instead, these standards describe a system that will help an organisation to achieve its own objectives and targets. The assumption is that better environmental management will lead indirectly to a better performance.

ISO 14001 (EMS – Specification with guidance for use), is the only certifying EMS standard and 14004 (EMS - General guidelines on principles, systems and supporting techniques) is the guidance for the implementation of ISO 14001.

Which organisations can go for ISO 14001 implementation?

ISO defines organisations as company, corporation, firm, enterprise, authority or institution, or part or combination thereof. Whether incorporated or not, public or private, it has its own function and administration. In other words, this means the organisation can be either involved in the process, service, administration or combination thereof. The elements of ISO 14001 are flexible by design to accommodate a wide range of organizational types and sizes (small, medium and large scale ranging in size from a couple of dozen employees to many thousands of employees).

Many facilities have multiple operating units at one location. For example, it is not uncommon to have a research and development (R&D) office at a production facility. The production facility may want to achieve ISO 14001 conformance, but not the R&D offices. As long as an auditor can clearly see the separation of these two activities, both physically and administratively, there should be little cause for concern.

 

The example above can be used to illustrate another point. If a large manufacturing facility had an R&D office on-site, there might be two distinct functional units that share physical resources but are separate cost centers. In some cases, units will actually pay each other for office space, utilities and janitorial service although they are part of the same corporation. In this case, separation for purposes of ISO 14001 program development and implementation is not difficult. Activities should be separate enough, however, to be clear to an outsider. If R&D engineers are constantly venturing out onto the production line and making changes in practices and procedures, it may appear to an auditor that they are a portion of the operational group for the facility. Separation of functional groups might be harder to argue.

An example of separation that may NOT be acceptable is separation of the purchasing function from the rest of an operation. Since purchasing is tied at almost every management level in an operation, this would seem unreasonable to most auditors, and could generate a concern in evaluating an ISO 14001 EMS program. The other example of separation that may be acceptable is complete separation of the supporting unit (industrial township) from the industrial certification process, this would seem reasonable to most auditors as there may not be impact of the township activities on the industrial activity.

In the EMS model described below the "Plan, Do, Check, Act" steps have been expanded into seventeen elements that are linked together. These EMS elements and their linkages are discussed in Fig1.

Why does an Organisation need ISO 14001 ?

ISO 14001 standard is built on Total Quality Management concepts. To improve environmental management, organization needs to focus not only on what things happen but also on why they happen. Over time, the systematic identification and correction of system deficiencies leads to better environmental (and overall organizational) performance. ISO 14001 standard are built on the "Plan, Do, Check, Act" model introduced by Shewart and Deming. This model endorses the concept of continual improvement.

Cost and time of implementing ISO 14001

There are two different costs in the implementation of ISO 14001 - direct and indirect cost. Direct cost involves two types of costs:

(i) Facilitation cost in implementation of ISO 14001 (may be by the external consultants) and

(ii) Third party certifying and periodic assessment cost. Indirect cost involves the managerial and other staff time cost spent for training the personnel.

Type of industry  Facilitators cost  Certifying Time required agencies or ISO 14001 cost implementation
  * Total no. of person days required   ** Cost per person days  
Small scale industry  26 - 28  Rs. 1 to 2 Lakhs Rs. 4000 to 6000 5 to 7 months
Medium scale industry 32 - 36 Rs. 1.5 to 3 Lakhs  Rs. 5000 to 8000 6 to 8 months
Large scale industry 36 - 50 More than Rs. 2 Lakhs  Rs. 6000 to 10000   7 to 15 months

Apart from the above costs, there is also a cost associated in implementation of the system as per the organisation’s environmental policy framed, which may be as per the framework of objectives and targets.

Facilitation cost by the external consultants depends on the number of person days and the charge per person days required for implementation of the system in a single facility i.e. in a particular site (see Table 1.).

In India there are around 18 certifying agencies for ISO 14001. Certification cost by the third party also varies from individual to individual agencies. Some of the factors determining the cost of certification are total employees working in the organisation, number of employees in each shift, total number of departments and the nature of activity / product / service the organisation is involved in.

Reasons to seek ISO 14001

Organisation can perform their ISO 14001 audits internally and declare that they are in compliance. Many feel that such "self-certifications" will have no credibility. However, self-certification will satisfy the ISO standard, and may offer certain advantages for firms who wish to develop internal practices that they do not want reviewed by external agencies. It is quite possible for such a firm to develop an ISO 14001 EMS, Self-Declare, and retain significant control over external review of the system.

Once there is a clear reason to demonstrate conformance to third parties, external certification and registration becomes a factor. Some reasons where certification becomes important are:

a) A customer requires EMS certificate as a condition
b) Due to world market pressure
c) Some export markets where EMS registration is a de facto requirement for entering the market
d) To satisfy major stakeholders (local community, shareholders, trade unions etc.)

Development Alternatives initiative in implementation of ISO 14001.

The Industry and Urban Environment Systems Group of Development Alternatives (DA) has more than two years of experience in facilitating ISO 14001 in various sectors.

The implementation of ISO 14001 is normally taken up by the process (manufacturing) sector. But DA has taken this beyond process to service sector. DA has rich experience in facilitating ISO 14001 implementation in service sector such as hotels and townships. q

How clean is the Water you are Drinking?
How safe is the Air you are Breathing?

Check it out with TARA Pollution Testing Kits!

Pawan-TARA is a brand new portable Air Pollution Testing kit which is low on price, high on quality and can be easily operated even by school children.

Jal TARA is a cost effective, portable, compact and easy to operate water quality testing kit developed by Development Alternatives. Jal TARA can assess 14 essential parameters to ensure that the water is fit for drinking.
For details, please contact:

TARA Environment Kit Division, Development Alternatives
B-32 Tara Crescent, Qutab Institutional Area, New Delhi - 110 016, INDIA
Tel: +91-11-685-1158, 696-7938; Fax: +91-11-686-6031; Email: tara@sdalt.ernet.in

 

Back to contents


Subscribe    Home   Contact Us About Us