The
relationship between the environmental degradation and
poverty is such an intriguing one that it has been a
favourite subject of development researchers. In fact,
Sage Publications has recently published a
well-researched book – ‘Migration, Common Property
Resources and Environmental Degradation’.
This book by Kanchan Chopra and SC
Gulati dwells upon the inter-linkages in India’s
arid and semi-arid regions. The authors’ hypothesis
is that the establishment of property rights through
institutional intervention is the key to mitigating
poverty and to stemming migration from rural to urban
areas. The document provides conclusive evidence
concerning the impact of institutional changes on
environmental upgradation and socio-economic
improvement.
This publication attempts to break
the prevailing urban myth that ‘poverty leads to
environmental degradation’. In fact, degradation of
the natural resource base in rural areas resulting in
degradation-pushed migration to urban areas suggests
just the reverse. It seems that degradation induced
poverty prevails in Rural India. The book explores
this complex nature of inter-linkages between poverty
and environmental degradation.
The authors suggest that the
resurrection of appropriate common property rights,
through interventions, in rural areas could hold the
key to stemming the tide of both distress
out-migration and environmental degradation. The study
has emanated as a result of a long-term interaction
with a large number of village based communities of
Rajasthan to understand the dynamics of their
behaviour vis-ŕ-vis natural resources, with the help
of local grassroots NGOs like Ubeshwar Vikas Mandal (UVM)
and Sewa Mandir. The document also reveals the harsh
realities of rural life and positive interventions by
the NGOs to ease the burden of the rural poor.
The study deals with the magnitude
of the vicious degradation-poverty cycle, in terms of
degraded common property resources, in the Indian
sub-continent as a whole and in arid and semi-arid
zones in particular. The major point of departure of
this study is the utilization of econometric
techniques to view institutional changes in rural
areas and determines its impact on environmental
upgradation, socio-economic conditions and distress
out-migration from rural tracts.
The study provides certain distinct
insights into the complex relationship between people
and the environment from which they derive their
livelihoods. At the same time, it depicts the
organizational evolution of the outside institutions.
It provides an analysis of the processes underlying
the evolution and working of the two organizations,
UVM and Sewa Mandir, representing two different
paradigms with respect to rural development.
The study concludes that
institutional change, induced mainly by non-government
organizations, positively influences the productivity
of natural resources by creating well-defined property
rights and the enforcing mechanisms. This results in
curtailing the out-migration from rural to urban
areas, as per the authors.
This important document is bound to
interest policy makers, NGOs and professional
economists as will as all those engaged in the
research on environment, common property and natural
resources.q Book
Review - by
Rajiv Gupta |