Transforming the Consumer Society

Aparajita Gogoi

Development Alternatives (DA) in conjunction with the US-based NGO Centre for Respect for Life and Environment (CRLE), organised a one-day conference on March 6, 1998 at the India International Centre, New Delhi. The conference was part of a series of dialogues between media representatives and leading thinkers on consumption issues.

A new reality today is the conundrum of consumerism.

Ironically, most of humanity is still at a bare subsistence level. There are some who survive at a slightly higher level of consumption. And then we have a few who participate actively in the global consumer market. And it is the lifestyles of this "few" which has led to a steep rise in wasteful and excessive patterns of consumption.

With globalisation, came wasteful consumption patterns. High-consuming lifestyles, that were once confined to the wealthy North, can now be found in the South too. The indicators of patterns of excessive consumption and the indiscreet use of resources are now visible virtually everywhere. Discarded plastic bottles, corroded cans, used tyres and rusting automobile parts form a part of the landscape even in the poorest nations. Children in our remote villages drink branded colas, eat potato chips out of flashy plastic packets manufactured by multinational corporations and demand gizmos they see advertised on TV- satellite and cable.

Unless this trend is reversed, the spread of high-consumption lifestyles will eventually exhaust the Earth’s resources. Poised on the brink of the twenty first century, we must find ways to bring our "Consumer Society" in balance with the carrying capacity of the earth.

These consumption patterns contribute to a wide range of serious problems across the earth.

Well-known environmental effects include increased air, land, and water pollution, deforestation and desertification, depletion of natural resources, habitat and wildlife destruction, migration of villagers lured by the citylights and interference in the ecosystem.

A consumerist culture also magnifies socio-economic disparities between rich and poor and political tensions are exacerbated between North and South over issues of industrialisation.

And, of course, the processes of production of consumer items for the constantly growing consumer markets are not eco-efficient.

These problems caused by acutely consumerist lifestyles can be arrested if all of us consciously adopt sustainable consumption patterns.

From an conjectural perspective, sustainable development will be seriously jeopardised unless and until sustainable consumption is attained. Production processes and economic development, depend a lot on consumer choice and thus these processes can be deeply affected by changes in consumer habits.

Agenda 21 did not define sustainable consumption, but clearly indicated that policy attention should be focused on the demand and the usage pattern of natural resources, so as to reduce pollution and prevent their fast depletion. The role of value judgements with respect to notions of equity in the given political-economic framework, was also given by the Agenda 21 statement which is as follows: "Measures to be undertaken at the international level for the protection and enhancement of environment must fully take into account the current imbalances in the global patterns of consumption of production", thereby throwing light on the existing consumption-inequity nexus.

The Second Oslo Symposium (1995) on Sustainable Consumption stated: "Sustainable consumption is an umbrella term that brings together a number of key issues, such as meeting needs, enhancing the quality of life, improving resource efficiency, minimising waste, taking a life cycle perspective and taking into account the equity dimension. Integrating these parts is the central question of how to provide the same or better services to meet the basic requirements of life and aspirations for improvement of both current and future generations".

Transforming the Consumer Society:  A Campaign

A campaign has been launched by Centre for Respect for Life and Environment (CRLE), to promote sustainable consumption. This project is designed to educate the public about the need to reduce excessive and wasteful consumption. The campaign, Transforming the Consumer Society, focuses on informing and sensitising strategic personnel in the world media community. A series of dialogues between representatives of the media and leading thinkers on consumption issues is under way.

The first of these events was held at the National Press Club in Washington, DC on December 4, 1997; and the second, co-organised by Development Alternatives, took place in New Delhi on March 6 ( see box ). Subsequent events are scheduled to be held this year in Rio de Janeiro on June 5, in Beijing on July 29, in Kampala on September 25, and in London on November 5.

Dialogue participants include experts on consumer movement, media strategists, educators, government officials, and corporate executives. At each dialogue, a media campaign against excessive consumerism, which is appropriate to that region is drafted, and planning for a series of subsequent media briefings on selected issues in the sustainable consumption arena is initiated. A kit for the media is in the process of being prepared which will be translated into the languages of the dialogue participants, for distribution to their colleagues and grassroots organisations active in sustainable consumption initiatives.

Four products will result from the series of dialogues. First, a printed report on the findings and conclusions of the dialogues will be published. Second, videotapes of the dialogues and interviews with key experts, business and governmental leaders will be compiled. These will later be edited to create PSAs for television and radio, as well as educational videos for distribution to schools, universities, and civic organisations. Third, a global information and communication network will be established on the World Wide Web to link organisations and interested individuals around the world actively supporting sustainable consumption projects. The network will provide libraries of resources, contacts and best practices, and international electronic discussion groups. The fourth product, to be prepared at the conclusion of the dialogue series, will be information resource kits for use by the media. These kits will provide specific information on projects that are successfully implementing sustainable consumption objectives, including contact information in order to encourage and facilitate coverage through feature stories, interviews and media programming.

As a result of the dialogues and the subsequent products, the campaign, Transforming the Consumer Society, hopes to contribute substantially in promoting sustainable consumption practices throughout the world.   q

A Ringside View of the Conference
Janaki Turaga

The participants at the conference on consumer issues came from many walks of life -environment, health, consumer protection groups, communicators, media / advertising, alternative energy initiatives, and reflected and debated on ways of changing current lifestyles.

Ashok Khosla, president of Development Alternatives, set the tone for the conference by highlighting the need for the identification of cultural metaphors and of an equitable consumption pattern leading to sustainable lifestyles. He also stressed that it is crucial to raise the floors, bring down the ceilings and plug the leaks. The need of the hour - plumbers.

Karon Brashares and Sharon Picket, the Centre for Respect for Life and Environment (CRLE) representatives stated the need for a world wide networking of groups, and national alliances of every country in transforming the prevailing/current consumption lifestyles. The website will soon be operational and can be used by the participants.

Major issues which emerged were the identification of the patterns of thinking, mindsets, the critical cultural metaphors and images, the ways of story telling and ways of changing lifestyles.

Everybody focused on inner change as the critical leverage point, but were undecided on how to bring about the change within individuals. Many participants articulated the felt need for inner change, without which outer change was not possible. But, there was not adequate clarity in identifying what constitutes inner change, its stimulus etc. Attention shifted to culture- its values and symbols which would help in catalysing inner and outer changes.

Swami Agnivesh, a well-known social activist, emphasised the primacy of the inner human urge to change and the need to understand the transformative process, enabling one to bring about inner change, the individual spiritual paradigm, and reiterated the basic values of truth, justice, compassion and love.

Gandhiji was used by Kamala Choudhary, a member of the Earth Charter, as a symbol of inner change, an initiator of a movement who captured the public imagination and support by utilising the right symbols - salt and khadi. She also raised a question about the current ecological/ environmental symbols.

For a few, the need for a single leader on the lines of Gandhiji was paramount, though many felt that the need was for identifying local leaders who would pick up today’s symbols and would relate and reach out to the public. New tools have to be evolved; the forgotten values of Indian culture have to be revived.

The consensus was that the need of the hour is to forge a national alliance, establish networks, identify the current issues, bring out a best practices book for the public.

The identified tasks were : identify the unifying symbols, leaders, issues, media strategies and campaigns.

The participants felt that the focus should be on:

Water conservation
Alternative energy sources
Green products
Green marketing
Green economics
Reduction on biomass
Public transport
Decentralised administration

The proposed campaign should focus on changing the media’s current predatory thrust on pushing a high unsustainable consumption lifestyle pattern. The strategy for this campaign should define a target group, identify the top five issues, frame a citizen’s charter in consonance with the consumers which has time bound commitments.

At this conference, one of the options of establishing a coordinating centre was debated -a centre where one could walk in not just for eco-friendly items, but also for information on "Green Consumerism". The broad outlines of the media strategy were discussed, and a specific strategy will be evolved over course of time in consultation with other concerned groups.  q

 Back to Contents

 
    Donation Home

Contact Us

About Us